Trying to catch up in the wild-card race, the Brewers instead saw the reigning NL MVP foul a ball off himself and go down with a broken right kneecap Tuesday night.
"We don't have a definitive time frame other than we know he will be out the remainder of the season right now," general manager David Stearns said after a 4-3 win over Miami. "We also don't know if surgery is required."
Yelich, who did not talk with reporters after the game, will travel to Milwaukee for additional tests on Wednesday.
The Brewers didn't say whether Yelich might be able to return for the playoffs that begin Oct. 1 if they make it that far. Milwaukee, which won its fifth in a row, closed within one game of the Chicago Cubs for the second NL wild-card spot.
"I just heard. That's not good," Cubs manager Joe Maddon said after a 9-8 loss in 10 innings at San Diego. "Listen, I always want to beat other teams at their best, so that's a tough one right there."
Yelich fouled a ball off his leg in the first inning. He was down on the ground for several minutes before limping off the field.
Yelich hit .329 with 44 home runs and 97 RBI along with 30 stolen bases this season. The outfielder was leading the majors in slugging percentage and OPS when he was hurt.
"We feel awful for Christian," manager Craig Counsell said. "That's the thing that resonates with me right now. He's a special player and it's a joy to watch him play every day. He's the best at what he does. Not being able to see that every day is not good."
The team learned the severity of his injury by the middle of the game.
"I went out there and his whole body was shaking," Counsell said. "I was concerned and when he got up and went down the stairs I was optimistic. Then we got the bad news."
Trent Grisham continued Yelich's at-bat with a 1-2 count and struck out -- the strikeout was charged to Yelich.
"Obviously awful, we all know Yeli and what kind of guy he is," said Marlins manager Don Mattingly, who had Yelich in his final two seasons in Miami before his trade to Milwaukee.
"You hate to see a player like that get hurt down the stretch. He's stepped into the superstar realm as a player, and MVP last year. You don't want to see that happen to a team down the stretch," he said.
It was 3-all when Yasmani Grandal led off the ninth with a single off Miami reliever Adam Conley (2-9) and advanced to third on Grisham's double. Pinch-hitter Austin's fly ball to medium center was deep enough to score Grandal.
Junior Guerra (9-5) got the win in two innings of relief while allowing Starlin Castro's solo homer in the eighth that tied it at 3. Drew Pomeranz pitched a scoreless ninth around two singles for his first save.
The Brewers regained their two-run advantage on Grandal's RBI double in the third before Diaz drove in another run with a single in the fourth.
Grisham will get additional playing time in Yelich's absence. The outfielder tied a team rookie game record with his five-hit outing Monday and his double continued the Brewers' go-ahead rally Tuesday.
"A big blow, what he means to this team and the year he's been having," Grisham said of Yelich's injury. "We wish him the fastest recovery he can get. It's exciting to help contribute and do my best to help win games."
ANDERSON VOTED MARLINS' MVP
3B/RF Brian Anderson was chosen the Marlins' 2019 Most Valuable Player by media members. Anderson, 26, currently leads the Marlins with 20 home runs, 33 doubles and an .811 OPS. His season ended on Aug. 23 after he was hit by a pitch that fractured a finger of his left hand against the Philadelphia Phillies.
Brewers: RHP Zach Davies (9-7, 3.69) snapped a five-game losing streak in his previous start, when he limited the Cubs to one run through five innings in a 7-1 win Sept 6.
Marlins: RHP Pablo Lopez (5-8, 4.75) benefited from a 16-run support in his previous start of the season against the Brewers on June 4. Lopez pitched six shutout innings in Miami's 16-0 win.
More AP MLB coverage: https://apnews.com/MLB and https://twitter.com/AP-Sports
Tyler Glasnow: Tipping 'obvious' but not the issue in Rays' Game 5 loss
While Rays starter Tyler Glasnow said it was "pretty obvious" he was tipping his pitches Thursday night, both Tampa Bay and Houston said that wasn't what did in the Rays in the ALDS.
Dominant Gerrit Cole again too much for Rays as Astros reach ALCS
Astros ace Gerrit Cole stifled the upstart Rays for the second time during the ALDS and continued his historic run with 10 strikeouts over eight dominant innings Thursday night.
Perez on ALCS: 'I just want it to go 7'
Eduardo Pérez and Tim Kurkjian break down Gerrit Cole's Game 5 dominance and look ahead to the much-anticipated ALCS between the Yankees and Astros.
A's rookie catcher Sean Murphy undergoes knee surgery
Athletics rookie catcher Sean Murphy has undergone surgery on his left knee and is expected to be fully recovered for the start of spring training in February.
Houston Astros-New York Yankees in ALCS a matchup for the ages
Classic matchups, power at the plate and on the mound, big names aplenty. What's not to love about the ALCS we've been counting on for months?
Cole: Astros responded to the Rays' test
Gerrit Cole is elated after the Astros eliminate the Rays in Game 5 and recaps the difficult series.